Ploughman’s with Homemade Pear Butter for Sunday Lunch
Homemade pear butter, a round of Moonstruck Baby Blue, dill pickles, a loaf of fresh ciabatta and perhaps the last tomato from the plants that have become like friends — very generous friends — during their 41/2 months in the pots around our picnic table.
Early fall on Pender: the harvest is in, the sun is playing a re-run of its summer splendour, and there’s nothing to do but enjoy it all with a lingering liquid lunch, at said picnic table, on the back deck. Oh, there’s tomatoes to trash, leaves to rake and garlic to plant…but not today.
Today, we’re on island time.
Fruit butter brings homemade sweetness to a quick winter’s breakfast of toast and coffee, or makes a rich, honeyed base for cheese on crackers. Add some red wine, and you have a party in front of the fire when the power goes out (which it does here on a semi-regular basis during the winter). It also makes amazing Christmas gifts.
However you use it, the 3 hours spent in the kitchen making it are TOTALLY worth it.
Homemade Pear Butter
Yield: (6) 250ml jars
| Bartlett pears, peeled, cored and roughly chopped | 3 kg (about 12 large) |
| Cider Vinegar | ½ C |
| Lemon Zest | 1 lemon |
| Vanilla Bean | 1 whole, split |
| Salt | ½ t |
| Sugar | 2 C |
kg= kilograms C=Cup t=teaspoon
In a large saucepan combine the pears, vinegar, lemon zest, vanilla bean halves and salt. Cook gently over medium-low heat until the pears are very soft and begin to break up – about 30-40 minutes. Remove from heat and remove the vanilla bean, but do not discard.
Puree the pears in a food mill fitted with fine plate, or use a spatula (and a little muscle) to force the pears through a fine sieve. Discard the very small amount of fibrous pulp that you won’t be able to get through the sieve.
Scrape the seeds from the now cooled vanilla bean and add them, as well as the pear puree and sugar, to a clean pot over medium-low heat. Cook, stirring often, until the pear butter is thick and mounds high on a spoon – about 1–1½ hours. Reduce the heat slightly as the mixture thickens to avoid it scorching on the bottom of the pot.
Fill sterilized 250ml jars, and process in a boiling water canner for 10 minutes.
Notes:
- In my last batch, I used 2 whole star anise instead of the vanilla bean. I removed them before putting the pears through the sieve, and then added them back, whole, to the puree while it cooked. My instincts about a good match between the licorice and the pear were totally substantiated, and even the doubters (Howard) had to admit it was probably better than the vanilla version from last year.
- I also used ½ a preserved lemon rind, finely minced, instead of the zest. We noticed a deeper (yet still subtle) taste of citrus from the preserved lemon. Either are lovely — use what you have.






















Thanks for stopping by my blog :o) I love this pear butter recipe. It looks flavorful and amazing and since I’m always looking for great food recipes around Christmas time I’m bookmarking this. Thanks for sharing!
Ah, one of my favorite meals–simple and flavorful! The pear butter sounds superb!
My mother makes apple butter. It’s always a favorite on toast and pork chops. I’ll have to give pear butter a try!
thank you for visiting my blog. this recipe sounds very good. i cant wait to give this a try. have a nice day.
[...] Recipe from Island Vittles [...]
Hi – could you substitute apples for the pears?? I have about 20 pounds of donated apples from a friend and need to use them up…there is only so much crisp you can make :)
thanks Maureen
Apple Butter is just as delicious. If the apples are on the tart side, I might up the sugar a little, but it all depends on your tastes. Go for it Maureen! Theresa
Theresa! It is delicious – i think I ate half a jar just testing the sugar level. You were right – the apples were nice and sweet I only had to add 1/2 cup of sugar. You have made my Apple Butter loving nephew very happy as he will be the recipient of most of the batch…i will definately try this with pears….Thank you again for another stunning recipe.
Mo
Mo — great news! And just so you know, tasting calories don’t count…that’s why chefs are all so svelte…;) Theresa